How to Make a Home Offer: Offer Comparison Worksheet, Contingencies, and Negotiation Steps
home offersbuying a homeoffer contingenciesreal estate negotiationbuyer checklist

How to Make a Home Offer: Offer Comparison Worksheet, Contingencies, and Negotiation Steps

TTop Real Homes Editorial Team
2026-11-17
7 min read

Learn how to make an offer on a house with a practical checklist for price, earnest money, contingencies, concessions, and negotiation.

Knowing how to make an offer on a house means looking beyond the purchase price. This guide gives you a repeatable home offer checklist, explains the main contingencies, and provides comparison worksheets for weighing price, concessions, timing, and risk before you sign.

Overview

A written offer is both a proposed purchase agreement and a statement of how much uncertainty you are willing to accept. It usually addresses the price, earnest money, financing, inspection rights, appraisal, closing date, included items, deadlines, and remedies if either party does not perform. The exact form, terminology, and deadlines vary by location, so review the offer with a qualified local real estate professional and, when appropriate, an attorney.

The strongest offer is not always the one with the highest price. A slightly lower offer with reliable financing, a workable closing date, and clear but reasonable contingencies may be more attractive to a seller than a higher offer with substantial uncertainty. Your goal is to make the offer competitive without giving up protections you need.

Before writing, review comparable homes and local conditions. Inventory, days on market, price reductions, and the number of competing buyers can affect how much negotiating room you have. For a repeatable approach, see how to read local real estate market trends and use a property scorecard when comparing homes for sale.

How to estimate

1. Establish your financial ceiling

Start with the amount you can comfortably spend, not simply the maximum a lender may approve. Account for the down payment, earnest money, closing costs for buyers, moving expenses, immediate repairs, and a reserve for routine ownership costs. Ask your lender to model the complete monthly payment, including principal, interest, property taxes, insurance, association dues, and any applicable mortgage insurance.

A mortgage pre-approval can support your offer, but it is not a guarantee that the loan will close. Confirm how changes in the purchase price, appraisal, interest rate, loan program, or down payment would affect your approval and cash requirement.

2. Set an offer-price range

Build three numbers: a target offer, a price you would accept only under favorable terms, and an absolute walk-away limit. Compare the home with recent, genuinely similar sales and adjust for condition, location, size, upgrades, and unusual features. A listing price is an asking point, not proof of market value.

Do not use a high offer to solve an affordability problem. If the price is above your comfort range, consider whether a seller credit, repair allowance, or different closing date would provide more value than increasing the price.

3. Choose earnest money deliberately

Earnest money is a deposit showing that you intend to complete the purchase. The amount and deadline depend on local practice and the contract. It is typically held by an escrow holder and credited toward your required funds at closing if the transaction proceeds, but the contract should explain when it may be refunded or at risk.

Ask where the deposit will be held, when it is due, what happens if a contingency is used, and what documentation is required to release it. Never assume that earnest money is automatically protected in every situation.

4. Select contingencies and deadlines

Contingencies create conditions that must be satisfied before you are fully obligated to close. Common provisions include:

  • Financing contingency: Gives you a defined process for obtaining the stated loan. Clarify the loan type, application deadline, commitment deadline, and required notices.
  • Inspection contingency: Allows inspections within a specified period. The contract may permit cancellation, repairs, credits, or renegotiation, depending on its language.
  • Appraisal contingency: Addresses a valuation below the contract price. Possible responses may include renegotiating, bringing additional cash, challenging the valuation, or ending the contract if permitted.
  • Sale-of-home contingency: Makes the purchase dependent on selling another property. This can protect your cash position but may make the offer less appealing to a seller.
  • Closing-date provision: Sets the target date and may address possession, a rent-back arrangement, or delays caused by financing and title work.

Contingencies should be specific enough to manage deadlines and risk. Waiving one may make an offer more competitive, but it can also leave you responsible for costs or performance if the expected event does not occur.

5. Define concessions, repairs, and included items

If you request a seller credit, state its purpose and confirm with your lender that it is permitted under your loan terms. Credits may be limited by the loan program, the buyer's closing costs, or the contract. If asking for repairs, identify the issue, requested remedy, and timing rather than relying on a general promise.

List items that must remain with the property, such as specific appliances, fixtures, window treatments, or outdoor equipment. Put important agreements in the written offer or an approved addendum; verbal understandings are difficult to enforce and easy to misremember.

Inputs and assumptions

Use the following worksheet for every serious property and update it when a counteroffer arrives:

Offer inputYour entryQuestion to answer
List price and proposed price$_____Does the price fit comparable sales and my maximum?
Earnest money and due date$_____ / _____How is the deposit protected and credited?
Down payment and loan type$_____ / _____Has the lender reviewed this exact structure?
Estimated buyer closing costs$_____What cash is needed in addition to the deposit?
Inspection period_____ daysCan inspections and follow-up estimates be completed?
Appraisal and financing deadlines_____ / _____Are the dates realistic for the lender?
Requested seller credit or repairs$_____ / _____Are they allowed and clearly documented?
Closing and possession dates_____Do they work with my lease, sale, move, and rate lock?
Sale-of-home conditionYes / NoWhat happens if my current home does not sell?

For each number, record the source and date: lender estimate, inspection quote, comparable analysis, listing information, or your own budget. This makes the decision auditable when emotions rise or terms change.

Worked examples

Suppose two homes are similar in condition and location. Offer A has a higher price but requires you to close quickly, provides limited inspection time, and includes no seller credit. Offer B is priced lower, allows a longer inspection period, and includes a credit that your lender confirms can be applied to eligible closing costs.

Compare the complete terms rather than the headline price:

TermOffer AOffer BWhat to evaluate
Purchase price$_____$_____Difference in payment, cash, and appraisal exposure
Seller credit$0$_____Usable amount after lender and contract limits
Inspection period_____ days_____ daysTime to inspect, obtain estimates, and decide
Financing riskLow / medium / highLow / medium / highLoan structure, documentation, and deadline
Closing date__________Moving costs, lease end, and seller preference

To compare the financial effect, estimate the net cash required at closing: down payment plus buyer closing costs and prepaid items, minus the earnest-money credit and any permitted seller credit. Then estimate the monthly payment and keep a separate reserve for repairs. A credit may reduce immediate cash needs without making the home cheaper, while a lower price may reduce both the loan amount and payment. Your lender can calculate the exact effect.

When a seller counters, write down every change. A higher price paired with a larger credit is not automatically better; its value depends on loan limits, eligible costs, appraisal risk, and the cash you have available.

When to recalculate

Revisit the worksheet whenever an input changes, including the purchase price, down payment, interest rate, loan program, appraisal result, inspection findings, seller credit, closing date, or sale status of your current home. Recalculate before accepting a counteroffer and again before removing financing, inspection, or appraisal protections.

Also update your assumptions when local market conditions shift. A change in inventory or buyer competition can affect strategy, but it should not override your affordability limit. If inspection reveals significant work, price the repair, consider future maintenance, and decide whether the risk belongs in the offer or is a reason to walk away. For broader ownership planning, keep a repair record using a monthly home maintenance checklist.

Your final action list is simple: confirm your maximum price, obtain lender-approved numbers, select contingencies, set realistic deadlines, document earnest-money terms, compare the full cost of each counteroffer, and have the completed contract reviewed under local requirements before signing. Treat the offer as a risk-and-cost decision, not just a bid for the home. That approach gives you a clearer basis for moving forward or declining when the terms no longer work.

Related Topics

#home offers#buying a home#offer contingencies#real estate negotiation#buyer checklist
T

Top Real Homes Editorial Team

Real Estate Editor

Senior editor and content strategist. Writing about technology, design, and the future of digital media. Follow along for deep dives into the industry's moving parts.